What if Bella chose Jake?

[shieldmyloves]

There are several of you that would love to see Jake and Bella together....But did you ever think what would have happened if she chose him and then he imprinted on someone else? Bella would have ended up like Leah. But I bet Edward would have been there to pick up the pieces, therefore, EDWARD IS THE BEST MAN FOR BELLA.......

[Natasha♥]

I wouldn't be able to continue reading the book if she chose Jake. That would have been a horrible mistake. To me at least. Edward is perfect for Bella.

[shieldmyloves]

I totally agree with you...I could not of read the books either if she chose Jake. I was so mad when i had to read from Jake's POV. I didnt care what he thought or wanted...I had to read the series a few times and once i knew she chose Edward, i was okay with Jake's thoughts...I wish all of the books were from Edward's and Bella POV...Edward is more exciting then Jake

[iluvjacobblack (jb)]

Aug 17, 2009 14:28:33 GMT -5 shieldmyloves said:

There are several of you that would love to see Jake and Bella together....But did you ever think what would have happened if she chose him and then he imprinted on someone else? Bella would have ended up like Leah. But I bet Edward would have been there to pick up the pieces, therefore, EDWARD IS THE BEST MAN FOR BELLA.......

If she chose him there would have been no Renesmee so there would have been no one else. And since he was completely in love with her that would have made him THE BEST MAN FOR BELLA.

Quite personally I LOVED reading from Jake's POV, it was way funnier and more interesting even when he was down. That is not to say that I didn't like reading from Edwards POV but it was just more serious and "whoa is me".

[shieldmyloves]

I liked Jake when he was being Bella's friend. I am taking my time and reading New Moon again....During Eclipse and BD, Jake was not himself, his character changed. He was depressed and so meloncoli...Now that I am taking my time and reading, and not obsessing over BELLA and EDWARD's relationship, I blame Bella for Jake's unhappiness. Yes everyone knows that Jake is unhappy because Edward came back, but Bella used him to help her do dangerous things to hear Edward. If you read New Moon carefully she says things that Jake mistakes as her liking him more than a friend. For example...When Bella tells Jake he is sorta beautiful (page 192 NM) She says it because she envies his skin color, not because she thought he was hot! Jake would have been better for her if there was no such thing as Vamps and wolfs. But Edward was way more mature than Jake. I love that Jake is with Nessie...That is what was meant to be for Jake, not Bella. Just my opinion. I love how strong, stubborn and funny Jake is but he got annoying at times. I wanted to hear more about Edward's world, not the wolfs...

[iluvjacobblack (jb)]

t respect ur opinion shield, it was very thought out.

[charlotte17]

i love jake!!! but she suits edward and he is better for bella

[♥TWILOVE♥]

Edward and Bella are for each other and for no one else! They are perfect pieces of a puzzle. Jacob could be her soul mate if mythical creatures didn't exist though...

[magic]

Wow, what if Bella did choose Jake. I think Jake really cares about Bella, so she would be in good hands...

[ninjalissa]

I just think that Bella and Edward are like PB&J. I do think that Jake would have been good for Bella, but I don't think Bella would have been good for Jake.

[indbella]

but if bella chose jacob he wont be able to imprint on someone else because in breaking dawn he imprints on her daughter .. so if bella didnt end up with edward and have a kid jacob wont have someone to imprint on and he'll always love bella ..
but am glad jacob is single anyway =P