jaspers fault?

[twilight4ever1901]

I agree with anitsirc completely
If it hadn't happened we wouldn't have the whole team edward vs team jacob

[dreamlife109]

its not his fault... i wouldnt have been able to stop myself either if i was a young vampire like him...

[renesmee09]

I do not at any moment think that it was Jasper's fault. He would never intentional hurt Bella and she knows that. He just had a moment of weakness.

[obsessed]

I dont blaim Jasper for his reaction...however...my question is, does no one ever cut themselves at school? Do the females at school cycle? How does he control himself under those circumstances??

[chante]

yea its all his faul

[tiffiny]

Well they apparently aren't attracted to "cycle blood" because its "unclean" (there was a whole thread about that a while back), but I think the same thing.. Wouldn't some kind of accident happen at school... papercuts, someone falls and scrapes their knee, whatever...

oh and Jasper isn't a "young" vampire... He's just "new" (relatively speaking) to the Cullen's way of life... He's been around longer then Edward. He was around during the Civil War (that's when he was created), but when he started out he fed on humans and what not... He got tired of that way of life and of feeling everything every victim felt before/while he was killing them. He's just still a bit weak when it comes to resistence since he's been doing this the shortest amount of time.

[loveofmylife]

How could anyone blame Jasper. Just like Jessica said "the one that looks like he is in pain all the time". Poor Jasper he feels so bad about himself because of his self control even in to book three after Bella becomes a new born.

[Twilighting :)]

Well, if it wasn't the incident with Jasper- then it would be something else- something would have made Edward feel that Bella was in just too much danger while with him, and he'd have found an excuse to make her "safe". It's just the way he is.
The incident with Jasper would have happened no matter what- considering how clumsy Bella is and prone to bleeding often. Poor Jasper, he never went after her like that again, he learned his lesson. And so did Edward, thank goodness for that!

[bella4ever]

i dont think it is his fault i mean he barly leaning to control his hunger

[alicecullen]

No it's not his fault, he is just not that used to it yet.

[edwardsbella]

HECK NO! shes such a clutz lmao. only bella would get a paper cut with a room full of vampires! haha i do feel bad for jasper in breaking dawn tho! im not saying y! i dont wanna ruin for those who did read it yet! hehehe

[twilightfan00]

i agree with everyone else it was totally not his fault. he really felt terrible about what happened. and he is very new to the cullens eating habits! i like jasper!

[♥TWILOVE♥]

I don't blame him, it's an accident... It just so happens that Bella gets a papercut and Jazz is too close... He just can't resist and again he regrets doing it... He's a good vampire, it was just an accident...

[chante]

YES IT ALL HIS FAUTL

[ebtwilight]

no. It's in his nature.